Federal Judge halts attack on NY crisis pregnancy centers; affirms free speech

This is great news. Kudos to Chris Slattery and the prolife law groups who stood up to this attack on the first amendment.

Judge Halts New York City Law Attacking Pregnancy Centers

Judge Pauley, of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, concluded the law violates free speech saying the law’s “over-expansiveness is evident from its very language.” He was especially critical of the City’s desire to single-out crisis pregnancy centers with the new law.

“Defendants’ second argument–that Plaintiffs engage in commercial speech because they are provided an audience to whom they can espouse their beliefs–is particularly offensive to free speech principles,” the court declared.  “While Defendants apparently regard an assembly of people as an economic commodity, this Court does not.  Under such a view, flyers for political rallies, religious literature promoting church attendance, or similar forms of expression would constitute commercial speech merely because they assemble listeners for the speaker.”

******

The ACLJ represents EMC Frontline Pregnancy Centers and AAA Pregnancy Problems Center which operate a total of 13 crisis pregnancy centers across New York City. The pro-life legal group filed the lawsuit today on their behalf in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

Comments

[Alicia Boland]

Congratulations to Judge Pauley for his thoughtful, upstanding and just decision. I thank God for decent, intelligent forward-thinking judges like you.

[Eileen Peterson]

Alleluia- It is so nice when goodness wins!!